Infant Debate Club – Autumn 2

Our debate this half term was inspired by the festive period.

‘Which is best…Christmas or birthdays?’

The session began with a discussion about what a debate is and what rules we might need in place to ensure that our debate runs smoothly. We agreed that everyone’s opinion would be listened to (whether we agree with them or not), and as a group we would respect each other. Our debate question had no wrong or right answer. The children then got into two groups (Christmas and birthdays), discussed their ideas, and decided which ones they should use to get their views and opinions across.

This half terms debate certainly raised some strong opinions but the children approached the debate in a very mature manner. One year 2 pupil finished the debate and announced he had almost been convinced to change his mind by the opposition.

“I was ‘this’ close to changing my mind. I was almost convinced when you mentioned that decorating trees only happened at Christmas!”

Here are some of the comments made during the debate. What do you think?

“I like birthdays best because it’s all about you and you get treated like the centre of the universe!” Year 2

“I like the Christmas decorations and food better.” Year 1

“You celebrate birthdays all year round, not just in December.” Year 2

“Christmas is better because it’s when Jesus was born.” Year 1

“For your birthday you might get a party or a day out with friends.” Year 2

“Christmas is better because you get to decorate a lovely tree.” Year 1

“I enjoy birthdays because I like to celebrate everyone’s with them.” Year 1

“Christmas is better because you get to spend time with all of your family, sometimes on birthdays you have a party and not everyone can come.” Year 2